India, a rising global power, finds its progress inextricably linked to the stability of its immediate neighborhood. Situated at the heart of South Asia, it shares borders with a diverse set of nations, each with its own unique set of internal and external challenges. However, the political and economic instability in three of its key neighbors—Nepal, Sri Lanka, and Pakistan—presents a persistent and multi-faceted challenge to India’s security, economic interests, and regional aspirations. This analysis delves into the underlying causes of this instability, examining specific case studies and the profound implications for India.
—
Nepal
Nepal’s recent history has been marked by a constant churn of political instability. A nation with a young population and deep-seated social issues, Nepal’s recent upheavals are a stark reminder of the fragility of its democratic institutions.
Background and Causes of Instability:
Political Fragmentation and Corruption: Since its transition to a republic in 2008, Nepal has seen a rapid succession of governments, with no prime minister completing a full term. This political flux has been fueled by intense rivalries between parties and a pervasive culture of corruption. This has eroded public trust in political leaders and institutions. The recent “Nepo Kids” controversy, where the lavish lifestyles of politicians’ children were flaunted online while ordinary citizens faced economic hardship, became a symbol of this deep-seated resentment.
Economic Distress and Youth Disenfranchisement:
With a high youth unemployment rate and a lack of opportunities, a significant portion of Nepal’s young population is forced to seek employment abroad. The remittances they send back constitute a major part of the country’s economy. This mass migration, however, is a clear indicator of the government’s failure to provide a future for its own people, creating a generation of disillusioned citizens who are ripe for mobilization.
Geopolitical Competition:
Nepal’s unique geographical position, sandwiched between two giants, India and China, makes it a site of geopolitical competition. There is a persistent fear of external interference from both sides. While India has a long history of close cultural and economic ties, its occasional perceived “big brother” attitude, such as the 2015 blockade, has pushed Kathmandu to seek closer ties with Beijing, which in turn has provided significant infrastructure and financial support.
Case Study: The Gen Z Uprising of 2025
The recent protests that led to the resignation of Prime Minister K.P. Sharma Oli serve as a powerful case study. The immediate trigger was the government’s ban on several social media platforms. However, this act of censorship was the final straw for a generation fed up with corruption, unemployment, and nepotism. The youth-led movement, galvanized online and drawing inspiration from similar uprisings in Bangladesh and Sri Lanka, quickly spiraled into nationwide demonstrations, showcasing the power of a digitally connected and frustrated populace to bring about abrupt regime change.
—
Sri Lanka
Sri Lanka’s instability stems primarily from a devastating economic crisis, which has in turn fueled a political and social breakdown. Once a model for economic development in the region, the island nation’s rapid decline offers critical lessons.
Background and Causes of Instability:
Unsustainable Debt and Mismanagement: A series of poor economic decisions, including massive tax cuts and a ban on chemical fertilizers, compounded the country’s pre-existing financial vulnerabilities. The reliance on foreign loans, particularly from China for large-scale infrastructure projects that failed to generate returns, created an unmanageable debt burden.
Political Cronyism and Dynastic Rule:
The Rajapaksa family’s prolonged hold on power led to a concentration of authority and a lack of accountability. Key government positions were held by family members, leading to widespread allegations of corruption and a policy-making process that was opaque and self-serving.
Impact of Global Events:
The COVID-19 pandemic severely hit Sri Lanka’s tourism industry, a key source of foreign exchange. The subsequent war in Ukraine further exacerbated the situation by driving up global fuel and food prices, pushing the country to the brink of collapse.
Case Study: The 2022 Economic Crisis
The 2022 crisis was characterized by mass protests, food and fuel shortages, and rolling blackouts. The public fury was directed squarely at the Rajapaksa family, whose lavish lifestyle was seen as a cruel irony against the backdrop of national suffering. The protests culminated in demonstrators storming the presidential residence, forcing President Gotabaya Rajapaksa to flee and resign. India’s swift and substantial financial assistance, including a Line of Credit, was crucial in helping the country navigate the immediate fallout, showcasing a practical example of its “Neighbourhood First” policy in action.
—
The Perennial Power Struggle: Pakistan
Pakistan’s instability is a complex web of political, military, and economic factors. The country has been in a state of perpetual crisis since its inception, with the civilian government often playing second fiddle to the powerful military establishment.
Background and Causes of Instability:
Civil-Military Tensions:
A key source of instability is the perennial power struggle between the civilian government and the military. The armed forces have a dominant role in national security and foreign policy, often interfering in the democratic process and leading to the ouster of elected leaders.
Economic Fragility and Debt:
Pakistan’s economy has been plagued by a crippling debt burden, soaring inflation, and a lack of consistent policy. This has led to frequent reliance on International Monetary Fund (IMF) bailouts, which often come with austerity measures that further burden the common populace. The close financial ties with China, particularly through the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), have also raised concerns about debt traps.
Rise of Extremism and Cross-Border Terrorism:
The presence of various militant and extremist groups operating from Pakistani soil poses a direct security threat not only to its own citizens but also to its neighbors, especially India. These groups, often with a nexus with state actors, have been a constant source of tension and a barrier to any meaningful dialogue.
Case Study: The Ouster of Imran Khan
The ouster of Prime Minister Imran Khan in 2022, though a parliamentary maneuver, was widely seen as a result of his falling out with the military. His subsequent arrest on corruption charges triggered violent, nationwide protests, highlighting the deep political divisions and the volatility of the country’s political landscape. This cycle of elected leaders being removed or sidelined has prevented any long-term political or economic stability from taking root.
—
India’s Stakes and Strategic Response
The instability in these three nations has significant implications for India. It presents security challenges, such as the potential for refugee influx, cross-border crime, and the escalation of militant activities. Economically, it disrupts trade routes and investment, while diplomatically, it forces India to constantly balance its foreign policy objectives.
India’s “Neighbourhood First” policy seeks to address these challenges by prioritizing engagement, connectivity, and mutual benefit. However, the path is fraught with complexities. While India has been successful in providing humanitarian and economic assistance to Sri Lanka and Nepal, its relationship with Pakistan remains stalled by the issue of cross-border terrorism. The increasing influence of China in the region adds another layer of complexity, with Beijing leveraging its economic might to gain strategic footholds.
For India, the key lies in a nuanced approach: maintaining robust defense and border security, providing timely and effective assistance to its neighbors in times of crisis, and fostering people-to-people connections that transcend political differences. The fate of India’s stability and prosperity is, to a large extent, tied to the fortunes of its neighbors. A stable, prosperous, and peaceful South Asia is not just an ideal—it is a strategic imperative.